Perfect Formula, Unfortunate Product

It’s not every day you come across a media that follows a familiar formula but fails to strike the right balance, resulting in a mix of success and failure. Meet The Perfect Insider, a modified formula that excels in some aspects while fumbling in others.

Episodes 1-2 Review

Subete ga F ni Naru: The Perfect Insider is based on the novel series penned by Hiroshi Mori, a former researcher and associate professor in the department of architecture. The story revolves around the teacher-student duo, Sohei Saikawa and Moe Nishinosono, as they unravel various murder mysteries. While this setup may seem familiar, the characters offer a fresh twist to the classic genius-sidekick trope.

Saikawa, an associate professor, is an insufferable genius, while Nishinosono, a cute and smart girl, adds a touch of high society charm to the mix. Their dynamic creates an intriguing atmosphere, with Saikawa’s eccentricities occasionally becoming more annoying than charming.

Episodes 3-6 Review

As the story progresses, the murder mystery deepens, and new revelations come to light. However, the characters themselves fail to leave a lasting impression, and their attempts at deep conversations often fall flat. The focus on solving the case proves to be more enjoyable than the characters around it.

Episodes 7-9 Review

The Perfect Insider reaches its climax when it is revealed that the supposedly dead Dr. Shiki Magata is alive, and her daughter’s corpse was mistaken for hers. As the investigation delves deeper into the motive behind these murders, the show thrives on revealing unexpected twists and turns. However, some character interactions still leave much to be desired.

Episodes 10-11 Review

In the final episodes, the investigation culminates in a revealing confrontation between the suspects. The answers to the “whys” and “hows” of the murders, however, feel half-baked and poorly conceived. Despite this disappointment, the show manages to provide some shining moments, such as the unexpected reveal of the culprit and a heart-to-heart conversation between Saikawa and Nishinosono.

In conclusion, The Perfect Insider is a show that falls short of being exceptional. It offers both intrigue and mediocrity, making it a somewhat satisfying choice for those with an academic interest in dissecting the mechanics of the story. However, for those seeking pure entertainment and a smart, satisfying narrative, there are better options available, such as Monster or Death Note.

Fecomic